The Role of Medical Evidence in SSDI Claims

December 7, 2023

By Steve Fields
Principal Attorney

Navigating the complexities of Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) can be challenging, especially given the stringent medical and technical requirements for all applicants. One of the key elements in the SSDI application process is the role of medical evidence.

In SSDI claims, medical evidence typically holds the highest priority. While the Social Security Administration (SSA) does assess other factors, a significant number of applications are rejected due to insufficient medical evidence, underscoring its importance.

Continue reading as we delve deeper into the intricacies of SSDI claims and the pivotal role of medical evidence.

Role of Medical Evidence in SSDI Claims

In the world of SSDI claims, medical evidence is not just a requirement—it’s the linchpin. It forms the foundation of your application, offering the necessary substantiation of your disability. The SSA utilizes this evidence to gauge the severity of your condition and its impact on your work capabilities.

While the SSA does consider other factors such as your age, education, and work experience, the lack of adequate medical evidence can lead to the denial of your application. In fact, a substantial number of applications are turned down each year due to insufficient medical evidence, emphasizing its crucial role in the approval process.

However, it’s not merely about possessing medical evidence—it’s about having the appropriate kind of medical evidence. The SSA seeks comprehensive and current medical records that clearly document your condition and its effects on your daily life. This encompasses everything from doctor’s notes and lab results to imaging studies and mental health records.

The process of gathering evidence is one of the most significant steps in submitting a claim for Social Security benefits. Medical evidence is the primary factor that the SSA considers when deciding whether to approve a claim for SSDI or Supplemental Security Income. 

While evidence is sometimes required for matters unrelated to the disability, such as income or employment history, in most cases, medical records hold the utmost importance. The SSA mandates the provision of adequate, timely, and accurate medical documentation. Remember, your medical evidence is the key to unlocking the door to your SSDI benefits.

What Is Timely, Accurate, and Adequate Medical Evidence?

When it comes to SSDI claims, the terms “timely,” “accurate,” and “adequate” are often used to describe the ideal characteristics of medical evidence. Let’s delve into what each of these terms means:

Timely Medical Evidence 

The SSA prefers medical records that are current, ideally not older than six months. Records older than a year are generally not considered “timely.” However, the SSA does value “longitudinal” medical records, which are records from multiple sources over a period. These can be crucial in determining the severity of a claimant’s condition, especially for SSDI claims involving retroactive disability back pay.

Accurate Medical Evidence

Accuracy in medical records is paramount. If the SSA finds inconsistencies in your medical records, they may disregard that evidence during the evaluation process. For example, if your doctor’s notes state that you cannot lift weights over 10 pounds, but your exercise log suggests otherwise, the SSA may disregard the latter.

Adequate Medical Evidence

Adequacy refers to whether your medical records provide enough specific information for the SSA to draw a sound medical conclusion about your impairments and how they affect your daily life. If the SSA doubts the sufficiency of your medical records, they may either request more information from your doctors or schedule a consultative examination for you.

In summary, providing timely, accurate, and adequate medical evidence can increase your chances of being approved for SSDI benefits. It can also expedite the application process by reducing or eliminating the need for the SSA to contact your doctors for additional information.

Types of Important Medical Evidence 

Objective medical records are crucial pieces of evidence in SSDI claims. These include results from imaging tests such as X-rays, CT scans, MRIs, and IMGs, which can help establish a diagnosis and demonstrate the extent of any orthopedic or brain damage. However, these alone may not be sufficient to win your case.

Supporting medical notes from a doctor, a qualified physician assistant, or a nurse practitioner are also required to bolster your chances of approval. These notes should align with the objective evidence and should not contain any discrepancies or missing information. If your treating provider writes a letter or fills out a medical source statement, it can be helpful for your claim.

Interestingly, it’s not just any medical opinion that matters. While doctors may provide their medical opinions on various subjects, including whether a patient is “disabled,” the SSA only considers opinions on specific topics to determine a person’s eligibility for Social Security disability benefits. 

Medical opinions regarding whether a patient is disabled are surprisingly not helpful to the SSA. Instead, it values medical opinions on how the patient’s condition impacts their ability to work or carry out certain tasks. 

These kinds of medical opinions are referred to as Residual Functional Capacity (RFC). Evidence of RFC is crucial to a disability claim, but it is often not included in routine medical records. 

Many medical professionals write brief letters stating that their patients are disabled to assist them. However, these opinions are not beneficial to the claim. To compensate for this deficit, many disability lawyers have developed specialized questionnaires covering the most common impairments that may prevent their clients from working. 

Obtaining these opinions early in a case is ideal. It can be challenging to capture all the specifics for an individual case in a questionnaire, and it’s always beneficial to have some flexibility in case you need to clarify something.

What Happens if Medical Evidence Is Not Enough?

If the disability examiner determines that the applicant’s medical evidence is lacking, they may seek additional documentation from the applicant’s treating physicians or request a consultative examination. This examination, conducted by the applicant’s treating physician, aims to provide the SSA with the most up-to-date information about the applicant’s conditions.

Once the SSA has gathered sufficient medical evidence about an applicant’s condition, it can then decide on whether the applicant qualifies for disability benefits.

Conclusion

Medical evidence forms the cornerstone of an SSDI application. It’s the foundation upon which the SSA bases its decisions. Providing comprehensive medical evidence can significantly enhance your chances of SSDI approval. It’s also crucial to gather medical evidence from a variety of sources.

So, if you’re contemplating applying for SSDI benefits, remember the significance of medical evidence. It’s not merely a box to tick—it’s the key to demonstrating your eligibility and securing the benefits you need.

If you want to ensure that you provide all the necessary medical evidence to the SSA, consider reaching out to a disability attorney. They can assist you in collecting medical documentation and ensuring nothing is overlooked.

Author

Steve Fields is the founder and managing attorney at Fields Law Firm. Since founding the firm in 2001 he quickly established a reputation with his Personal Injury clients for being a lawyer who truly cares.

Together with his experienced team of legal professionals, Steve ensures clients win their case, maximize their recovery while also looking out for their long-term interests, all backed with the firm’s Win-Win Guarantee®.

Fields Law currently handles cases for Personal Injury, Workers’ Compensation, Long Term Disability, Social Security Disability and Consumer Rights and has grown to be one of the largest injury and disability law firms in the nation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *