Does Regular Social Security Pay More Than SSDI?

September 11, 2023

By Steve Fields
Principal Attorney

The Social Security program provides protection against the loss of earnings due to retirement, death, or a disability. To help those unable to work due to a disability, the US government provides benefits under the Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) program, and Social Security provides benefits at retirement age. Although the Social Security Administration (SSA) oversees both programs, several significant distinctions exist between them, including the amount of benefits paid out. 

Depending on the person’s age at the time they file for social security, regular social security benefits may pay more than SSDI benefits. Depending on the type of disability, age when the person applied for SSDI, and work history, SSDI benefits may pay more than regular social security benefits. The regular Social Security benefits received at full retirement age may be equal to SSDI benefits in most cases. Your payments won’t decrease after your SSDI benefits become regular Social Security retirement benefits. Supplemental Security Income (SSI) is generally less generous than SSDI.

This article will examine whether traditional Social Security pays more than SSDI.

Everything About Social Security And SSDI

Social Security is a federal program that offers disability, retirement, and survivor benefits to those who qualify. 

Depending on your work history and age, you must have received a specific number of credits to be eligible for Social Security retirement benefits. Your lifetime earnings determine your benefits, with higher earners receiving higher benefits.

The SSDI program, on the other hand, was created to offer payments to people who cannot work due to a disability. If your handicap is anticipated to persist for at least a year or result in your death, you may be eligible for SSDI. 

To qualify for these benefits, you will have to work and pay Social Security taxes for a specific number of years.

How To Calculate Benefits

Your Social Security or SSDI benefits are calculated using a complicated formula that considers your past earnings, history, age, and level of disability. 

Your benefits amount from Social Security retirement is calculated by your average indexed monthly earnings (AIME), which are obtained by dividing your greatest 35 years of earnings (adjusted for inflation) by 420 (the total number of months in 35 years).

Your primary insurance amount (PIA), the sum you would receive when you reach full retirement age (now 66 or 67, depending on your birth year), is then calculated using your AIME. Your benefit amount will be decreased if you decide to start receiving benefits as early as 62 years of age. 

Your average lifetime earnings determine your benefit amount for SSDI before the onset of your disability. 

Your AIME is determined by dividing your greatest 35 years of earnings, adjusted for inflation, by 420, just like with Social Security retirement payments. However, the formula employs a different computation to establish your PIA for SSDI benefits. 

Which Pays More: Social Security or SSDI?

Retirement payments from Social Security typically outweigh benefits in terms of payout. It is crucial to remember that the number of benefits you receive can vary significantly based on your unique situation. 

Your age, your history of wages, and whether you decide to collect benefits sooner rather than later can all impact the benefits you receive. For instance, taking Social Security retirement benefits at age 62 will result in a 30% reduction in your benefit amount.  

You can only collect your entire benefit amount if you wait until you reach full retirement age. Currently, the retirement age is now 66 or 67, depending on your birth year. Like SSDI benefits, the amount you get depends on your situation. 

Your main insurance amount (PIA) is determined by the SSA using a complicated formula that considers your average lifetime earnings before you become and any additional benefits you might be entitled to.

While Social Security retirement payments and SSDI benefits are two programs, there may be connections between them. When you reach full retirement age while receiving SSDI benefits, your benefits will automatically transfer to Social Security retirement benefits. However, the amount you get will not change. 

Additionally, your SSDI benefits can be diminished if you get both SSDI benefits and retirement from work where you did not pay Social Security taxes.

How Are Social Security and SSDI Benefits Taxed?

The amount of tax you owe is determined by your income level and can be applied to both Social Security retirement payments and SSDI benefits. 

Half of your Social Security benefits could be taxed if you file an individual tax return and have a combined income between $25,000 and $34,000 (adjusted gross income plus nontaxable interest). Up to 85% of your benefits could be taxed if your total income is over $34,000.

How To Apply For Social Security Or SSDI Benefits

You can apply for SSDI or Social Security retirement benefits online, over the phone, or in person at your Social Security office. 

You must give information about your medical history, employment history, and proof of your impairment to apply for SSDI. Similar steps must be taken to apply for Social Security retirement benefits, but no proof of disability is necessary.

Eligibility For Social Security Or SSDI Benefits

Depending on your work history and age, you must have accrued a specific amount of credits to be qualified for Social Security retirement benefits. 

You will have to work and pay Social Security taxes for a predetermined period to qualify for SSDI payments and have a disability that is anticipated to continue for at least 12 months or result in death. Additionally, you must fulfill specific medical requirements to be eligible for SSDI compensation.

How Long Does It Take To Receive Benefits

The complexity of your case and a backlog of applications at the SSA, among other variables, can greatly affect how long it takes to get Social Security retirement benefits or SSDI benefits. After applying, it typically takes many months to a year or more to receive benefits.

Conclusion

Although SSDI payments normally pay more than Social Security retirement benefits, your benefits can vary greatly based on your unique situation. If a disability prevents you from working, you may be eligible for SSDI benefits, which can help you financially until you can resume working.

You may be qualified for Social Security retirement benefits if you are getting close to retirement age. These benefits might give you a reliable income stream during your golden years. 

Understanding the eligibility conditions and benefit amounts for both programs is crucial so that you can make decisions about your financial future that are well-informed.

Author

Steve Fields is the founder and managing attorney at Fields Law Firm. Since founding the firm in 2001 he quickly established a reputation with his Personal Injury clients for being a lawyer who truly cares.

Together with his experienced team of legal professionals, Steve ensures clients win their case, maximize their recovery while also looking out for their long-term interests, all backed with the firm’s Win-Win Guarantee®.

Fields Law currently handles cases for Personal Injury, Workers’ Compensation, Long Term Disability, Social Security Disability and Consumer Rights and has grown to be one of the largest injury and disability law firms in the nation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *